I have chosen to benchmark the first episode of senses, not because it is the strongest, but because I feel that it is to compare with the benchmark. I will be using the BBC Radio 1 programme I hear Voices: Donna.
The Radio 1 programme starts similarly to senses with music being utilised as an opening, however in our episode, I have talked directly on top of the music, with me saying ‘Senses’ and explaining the episode before continuing to explain the premise of that episode, almost identically to what has been done in the Donna episode where the narrator is introduced and then explains her story. While the Radio 1 programme continues to go on with the narrator (Alice), Senses has already broken off into its first interview, showing the difference of styles as there are no interviews in the R1 programme. This shows the first difference in treatment, as senses is a combination of a podcast mixed with a documentary meaning that we have narration and interviews rather than just one single voice. Whereas in I hear voices there is just one voice as it is told through Alice’s own words. This could lead to people saying that it is more emotional and to that I would agree as this episode of senses is me telling my story but also involving others, whereas R1 is just Alice. In regards to the music that is used, we utilised similar genres with the slight difference being that we used a wider variety such as electronic and classical, whereas R1 used just one piano track. If you listen carefully there is a jump in how Alice sounds at 02:04 where it sounds like she is being interviewed rather than narrating, we also applied this technique as I was interviewed by Chloe and we then cut the questions out to make a concise dialogue. Regarding overall levels, I feel that both are similar as they are in essence the same product and our piece doesn’t distort etc.